Cars
Car Insurance Costs Set to Surge Amid Rising Tariffs and Increased Claims
2025-03-05

The cost of car insurance is expected to rise significantly this year, with federal data indicating premiums have already increased by nearly 12% over the past 12 months. A recent study suggests that tariffs on imports from Canada and Mexico could accelerate this trend even further. Analysts predict a faster rate of increase in insurance costs, driven by higher expenses for auto parts and repairs. The impact of these tariffs extends beyond just car insurance, potentially affecting consumer prices across various industries.

Rising Car Insurance Premiums: The Role of Tariffs and Other Factors

In the current economic climate, the price of full-coverage car insurance has become a growing concern for many drivers. Data journalist Matt Brannon from Insurify explains that before any potential tariffs were introduced, the company anticipated a modest 5% increase in premiums by the end of the year. However, with proposed tariffs of 25% on imports from Canada and Mexico, this estimate has now risen to 8%. The average premium for full coverage in 2024 was $2,313, and without tariffs, it was expected to increase by $120 by the end of 2025. If tariffs are implemented, however, the cost is projected to exceed $2,500 by the same time.

The reasons behind this surge are multifaceted. Tariffs would make imported auto parts more expensive, which in turn increases repair costs. According to industry figures, approximately 60% of the parts used in U.S. auto repair shops come from Mexico, Canada, and China. Moreover, about one-fifth of cars and trucks sold in the U.S. originate from Canada and Mexico, with billions of dollars worth of auto parts being imported annually. This dependency on foreign components complicates efforts to shift production domestically, as certain parts are not manufactured in the U.S.

Beyond tariffs, other factors contributing to rising insurance costs include post-pandemic driving habits, the increasing complexity and value of modern vehicles, and a growing number of accident victims pursuing legal claims. These factors have led to insurers paying out larger sums for repairs and replacements, driving up premiums.

To mitigate these rising costs, consumers are advised to compare quotes from different insurers and explore safe driving incentive programs that may offer discounts.

From a reader's perspective, this news underscores the importance of staying informed about economic policies like tariffs, as they can have far-reaching effects on everyday expenses such as car insurance. It also highlights the need for proactive measures, such as comparing insurance options and adopting safer driving practices, to manage these rising costs effectively.

More Stories
see more