Retail
Taste Test: Ranking 37 Crumbl Cookie Flavors
2025-03-20

A food enthusiast recently embarked on an ambitious journey to sample and rank 37 different flavors of cookies from the popular chain Crumbl. The writer explored a diverse range of tastes, identifying personal favorites and less appealing options. Among the highlights were caramel apple and pink velvet flavors, while others like wedding cake and pistachio gelato received less favorable reviews. This article delves into the rapidly growing popularity of Crumbl, its expansion across North America, and the challenges faced when selecting among their extensive menu.

Exploring Crumbl's Sweet Selections

In the heart of the dessert revolution sweeping through the United States, one cookie company stands out for its innovative approach and rapid growth. Crumbl Cookies, originating in Utah in 2017, has expanded to over 1,000 locations spanning all 50 states, Puerto Rico, and Canada. Known for its weekly rotation of six unique cookie flavors, Crumbl offers customers a delightful challenge in choosing their next treat.

This particular taste test involved sampling an impressive 37 flavors over multiple visits. Each cookie was carefully evaluated based on texture, flavor balance, and overall appeal. Some standout winners included the caramel apple cookie, which combined rich cinnamon with salty-sweet caramel and fresh apples, creating a harmonious blend of textures and tastes. Another favorite was the pink velvet cookie, whose cream cheese frosting provided a perfect complement to its sweet, soft base.

On the other hand, certain flavors left a less positive impression. The wedding cake cookie, for example, was criticized as being overly sweet even for young children who typically adore sugary treats. Similarly, the pistachio gelato cookie was described as dense and bland beneath its vibrant frosting. These insights offer valuable guidance for future Crumbl enthusiasts navigating the vast array of choices.

From these experiences, it becomes clear that Crumbl’s success lies not only in its creative recipes but also in its ability to cater to diverse palates. Whether you prefer classic chocolate combinations or adventurous fruity creations, there is something for everyone at this beloved bakery.

As someone who appreciates both the artistry and science behind baking, I found this exploration of Crumbl’s offerings incredibly enlightening. It reminded me how subjective taste can be; what one person adores another may dislike entirely. This exercise reinforced the importance of trying new things and keeping an open mind when it comes to culinary adventures. Ultimately, whether you're seeking comfort in familiar flavors or excitement in unexpected pairings, Crumbl provides endless opportunities to indulge your sweet tooth while discovering new favorites along the way.

more stories
See more