The latest results from the National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) reveal a troubling trend in American education. Across the nation, students' performance in core subjects like reading and mathematics has seen a significant decline since 2022. The data highlights that nearly one-third of fourth- and eighth-grade students are struggling to meet basic reading proficiency levels for their age groups. This alarming drop marks the lowest scores recorded since NAEP testing began in 1992. Despite substantial federal funding aimed at mitigating pandemic-related educational setbacks, only top-performing students have shown signs of recovery. Consequently, the achievement gap between high-achieving and low-performing students is widening.

The challenges extend beyond reading into other critical areas such as mathematics. Eighth-grade math scores have declined over the past two years, while fourth-grade students have made modest gains—though these improvements remain below pre-pandemic levels. Interestingly, Catholic schools managed to avoid significant learning losses during the pandemic by reopening swiftly. In contrast, public schools in areas with strong teacher unions remained closed for extended periods, correlating directly with increased truancy rates post-COVID. New York's Comptroller Thomas DiNapoli highlighted that nearly one-third of students in the state are now chronically absent, raising serious concerns about the habituation of school attendance.

While additional funding for public education is often proposed as a solution, the evidence suggests that the issue lies not in the amount spent but in how funds are allocated. For instance, New York State invests over $36,000 per student annually, more than any other state, yet its students perform only moderately on national exams. The State Education Department's decision to stop reporting chronic absenteeism further undermines efforts to address the crisis effectively. Advocates for charter schools argue that these institutions, which operate largely outside union control, offer a promising alternative. Republican leaders, including those aligned with Team Trump, are championing school choice as the most viable solution to America’s education crisis. Ultimately, ensuring quality education for all children requires a reevaluation of current practices and a focus on innovative approaches that prioritize student success.