Retail
Former Federal Workers Rally Against Mass Terminations Despite Positive Reviews
2025-02-19

In recent developments, a significant number of federal employees have been terminated from their positions, citing performance issues. However, many of these workers had previously received glowing performance evaluations. This discrepancy has led to a growing movement among the fired employees to contest their dismissals through legal and administrative channels. The terminations primarily targeted probationary staff, who have fewer protections compared to long-term employees. Former employees are questioning the validity of these actions and are preparing to fight back, seeking reinstatement and justice.

The controversy began when thousands of federal workers received termination notices over the past week. These notices claimed that the employees did not meet the required performance standards. However, several former employees shared their recent performance reviews with media outlets, revealing positive feedback and commendations for their work. Melanie Mattox Green, a former U.S. Forest Service employee, was praised in her October review for her exceptional self-initiative and superior quality of work. Yet, she found herself among those let go last week. “It’s a low blow, and it’s completely baseless,” Green remarked, emphasizing the inconsistency between her reviews and the reason for her dismissal.

Thomas Wartenberg, another former U.S. Forest Service worker, echoed similar sentiments. Despite receiving positive reviews during his tenure, he was also terminated based on alleged performance issues. Wartenberg expressed frustration, stating that the terminations felt like a personal affront. He and other fired employees are now planning to appeal their dismissals and are considering joining potential lawsuits against the administration. The termination notices provided limited grounds for appeal, focusing only on discrimination or partisan political activity.

One USDA worker, who wished to remain anonymous, highlighted the emotional impact of the layoffs. They frequently received positive feedback from supervisors but were let go before they could receive formal performance metrics. This worker, along with many others, is now focused on finding new employment while hoping for a chance to return to what they considered one of the best jobs they ever had. The firings follow a memo issued by the Trump administration in early February, instructing agencies to identify underperforming employees. Probationary employees, who have fewer job protections, have been the primary targets of these terminations.

Michael Fallings, a partner at Tully Rinckey PLLC, believes the administration is using performance as a pretext because it must provide a reason for terminating probationary workers. While advanced notice is not required, the reasons given must be grounded in performance or conduct. David Rice, a 25-year Army veteran who worked at the Department of Energy, also faced termination despite his dedication and passion for his role. Rice is now working with his union and exploring legal options, hoping to find a way back to a job he loved. Many employees feel disillusioned by the abrupt nature of the terminations and are determined to seek justice through appeals and litigation.

The National Treasury Employees Union has already filed a lawsuit accusing the Trump administration of illegally firing federal workers en masse. Everett Kelley, president of the American Federation of Government Employees, vowed to fight these firings every step of the way. As the situation unfolds, fired employees are balancing the need to find new employment with their determination to challenge the administration's actions. The coming weeks will reveal whether their efforts will lead to reinstatement or further complications.

more stories
See more