The Arcade Theatre, a historic gem nestled in Fort Myers, has witnessed the ebb and flow of cultural trends since its establishment in 1915. Initially designed for vaudeville performances, it transitioned to showing motion pictures by early 1917. This building, crafted by Harvie Heitman and his brother Gilmer, not only entertained audiences with acts ranging from magic to plays but also became a cornerstone of community life. Over the decades, it showcased films like “Barbary Sheep” and “Jaws,” yet faced periods of disrepair and closure. Acquired by Bill Smith in 1979, the theatre is part of a sprawling complex that includes retail spaces, offices, apartments, and even a bank. Despite challenges, the Arcade Theatre remains a vital piece of Fort Myers’ history, symbolizing resilience through renovations and adaptations.

Constructed during an era when attending movies was considered a luxury, the Arcade Theatre boasted an elegant aesthetic reflected in its signage. Although details about the sign manufacturer remain elusive, historical records suggest installation occurred between a major renovation in 1938 and 1943. By the late 20th century, downtown Fort Myers had lost much of its allure following the exodus of large retailers such as Sears and JCPenney to the Edison Mall in 1965. Wilbur Smith, recalling those years, noted how deserted the area became, with most businesses shuttered by 1979. Yet, this downturn did not deter the Smith family, who saw potential in revitalizing the property.

Under the ownership of Bill Smith, the circa-1901 Bradford building underwent significant transformations. Spanning over 100,000 square feet, the structure encompasses more than just the theatre—it houses various commercial establishments and residential units across its expansive footprint. As downtown Fort Myers experienced a renaissance, attracting new tenants and visitors, one lingering reminder of its past remained—the darkened sign atop the Arcade Theatre. Recognizing its symbolic importance, the Smiths invested $80,000 to restore the sign's brilliance, illuminating both the physical space and the spirit of the community.

In 1998, the Florida Repertory Theatre began utilizing the venue, presenting diverse theatrical productions including comedies, dramas, original plays, and musicals. This shift marked another chapter in the theatre’s storied existence, ensuring its relevance in contemporary times while honoring its rich heritage. Today, the Arcade Theatre stands as a testament to perseverance and adaptation, continuing to play a pivotal role in enriching the cultural landscape of Fort Myers.

Through meticulous restoration efforts and innovative programming, the Arcade Theatre exemplifies the power of preservation and progress. Its journey from a bustling entertainment hub to periods of decline and subsequent revival mirrors the broader narrative of Fort Myers itself. As the city thrives, so too does this cherished landmark, shining brightly once again thanks to dedicated stewards like the Smith family. Their commitment ensures that future generations can experience the magic of live performance within these historic walls.